sitting on the edge of the sandbox, biting my tongue

December 20, 2012

The 1% Psycho

Filed under: education, society — Tags: , — edge of the sandbox @ 10:03 pm

The most famous crime in literature was committed with an axe.  Rodion Raskolnikov murdered the elderly pawnbroker and her sister to prove that she, the pawnbroker, is a worm but he is an ubermensch.  Dostoevsky used the story to illustrate the death of values in modernity.  Dostoevsky’s own morals are questionable, and so are his ideas about Russian history and society.  The early Russian translations of the late 19th century German philosophers whom Dostoevsky imagined to be an influence on Raskolnikov are notoriously imprecise.  And yet, in the aftermath of the Newtown massacre, how come no one is talking about Dostoevsky?

what would raskolnikov do?

Don’t worry, this onsie is organic.  It’s probably not quite a joke, and I wouldn’t be surprised if zazzle.com actually sold a few of these to expecting literature lovers

We hear quite a bit about psychiatry.  According to his brother, Adam Lanza, the man who slaughtered 20 children and 6 adults, was on the autism spectrum, which explains what was going on, to a degree.  It’s not a sufficient explanation because Mozart, for instance, was almost certainly autistic, and yet his ailment (which informed his genius) was a gift to humanity.

What strikes me about Adam Lanza is his self-centeredness.  Sources suggest that his mother wanted to institutionalize him, which, to be sure, sounds scary.  But check out what appears to be his rationale for the rampage: he felt his mother, the woman, who, whatever her faults, literally gave her life to him, loved a kindergarten class where she did some volunteer work more than her son, which prompted him to assassinate both his mother and her 6-year-olds.  Adam Lanza thought his mama didn’t love him enough.  That’s beyond Dostoevsky.  While some critics suggest that Roskolnikov’s figure is vaguely matricidal, Dostoevsky could not consciously imagine a son who felt that the woman who gave him life was insufficiently devoted.

Adam Lanza is so spoiled rotten American.  I don’t doubt that there were dangerous autistic people in Austria in Mozart’s time and that plenty of men and women who get autism diagnosis today are responsible gun owners.  And yet the alleged rational for the mass shooting sounds so very contemporary American kid talk.  Granted, that’s an explanation proposed by some third person, not the perpetrator himself, but jealousy does seem to be a motive.

The killer might had been wired differently from his peers, but he was functional enough to soak up the anxieties common to last several generations of Americans.  They might be some of the most privileged people in history (even the ones who, unlike Adam Lanza, weren’t born with a silver spoon in their mouth) growing up in spacious estates with dotting mothers watching their every move.  But they are perfectly content nurturing resentment of mom and dad and feel the need of spending years on a shrink’s couch pontificating about their feelings. I suspect that Lanza was not the only 20-year-old in his neighborhood who never had a job.  He didn’t move out of the house, but how many of his former classmates will end up boomerang kids, returning to their childhood rooms (and video game collections) after college?

I have no to tax the hell out of the 1%.  But my problem with them is this: so many upper middle class/upper class parents today forgo moral education.  Everything is relative and any behavior is explained away.  High school students are less likely to have part time jobs because they are busy with college prep classes.  This is the environment in which the Newtown killer was raised.  I’m not going to blame his mother; I suspect she didn’t do anything radically different from what any other woman of her background would do had she had a mad genius for a child.  It’s just that a little more moral education wouldn’t have hurt Adam Lanza — or any other American kid for that matter.  Too many privileged kids today do things because they can, even if that means murder.

About these ads

6 Comments »

  1. I think the American elites, as they have become secular, have replaced ‘morality’ with tantrums. And Obama appeals to that ethos.

    Comment by heathermc — December 21, 2012 @ 2:26 pm

  2. [...] Edge of the Sandbox: The 1% Psycho [...]

    Pingback by A Little Holiday Magic in New York: The Good, the Bad, and the Bad-Ass « Temple of Mut — December 22, 2012 @ 5:37 pm

  3. [...] The 1% Psycho [...]

    Pingback by Sunday Links: Facebook Friends Pics Edition Volume 46 — December 23, 2012 @ 7:18 am

  4. My literature classes and I have explored Crime and Punishment during two different and distant school terms. In the end, Raskolnikov was redeemed because he found the Christian faith of Sofia, the love of his life. Thus, it seems that Dostoevsky rejected the concept of the Übermensch as a pathway for morality and salvation. As you said in the post:


    Dostoevsky used the story to illustrate the death of values in modernity.

    Would that people right now would give some consideration to Dostoevsky’s conclusions in that novel!


    I don’t doubt that there were dangerous autistic people in Austria in Mozart’s time and that plenty of men and women who get autism diagnosis today are responsible gun owners.

    I agree!

    What was lacking on the Lanza household? Well, for one thing we have learned that the household was not faith based. In my own experience, those whom I personally know that are on the autism spectrum have a strong moral compass that is faith based.

    In my view, psychiatry and psychology don’t have the answers to anomalies such as Adam Lanza.

    ———————-

    At this point, I want to wish you a Merry Christmas, Edge. The world today does indeed need a Savior, and He came to earth to show us the Way centuries ago. Why do so many today fail to recognize that He is the only real Hope for our lives.

    Comment by Always On Watch — December 24, 2012 @ 7:58 am

    • AOW, you obviously know more about the subject being a teacher. I had heard on the mommy circuit that autistic kids don’t really get feelings and are not very relational. However, they have a keen sense of justice and need a strong moral foundation.

      Comment by edge of the sandbox — December 25, 2012 @ 12:03 pm


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Silver is the New Black Theme. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 322 other followers

%d bloggers like this: