Is Ethan Krupp Jewish because The Forward said so (via Instapundit)? I suspected the boy might be of Hebrew lineage when I saw the picture of the anonymous hipster clad in Christmas pajamas, but since my Jewdar is known to be too sensitive I figured I shouldn’t jump to conclusions. Then it turned out that the imp bares a not so nice surname. I seriously doubt that The Forward “fact checkers” require a poof of tribe membership as onerous as Chabad’s, so allow me to remain agnostic on the matter of boy Ethan’s Jewishness. Especially since, as it turns out, blacks also claim him.
In a very excellent post Susan L.M.Goldberg noted that Krupp is Jewish the way Marx was Jewish. Marx, who, if we recall, was born into a Christian German family, was haunted by his Jewfro and wrote anti-Semitic tracts. Similarly, boy Ethan is Jewish because somebody somewhere might think he looks like a walking Jewish stereotype, in which case Ethan himself is guilty of perpetuating said stereotypes. Why-oh-why couldn’t he style himself into a Zionist?
Needless to say, The Forward presented no evidence of any anti-Semitic right wingers pounding on poor Ethan because of his presumed Hebrew curls; I am yet to read of anyone saying: “That Jew, to the oven!” As RS McCain said:
Jay Michaelson [The Forward author] tells us very little about conservatives who made fun of a silly ad, but tells us an awful lot about the strange ideas that swirl around inside Jay Michaelson’s deranged mind.
A pj onesie could be good humor, but, evidently, not in an act performed by a hipster. Being a humorist is a tough job, a bit above the pay grade of the hopelessly insecure residents of Williamsburg. The insecure feel the need to create an air of superiority about them which destroys comedy. One can imagine Groucho Marx wearing pj’s, or Woody Allen (I’m pretty sure he did it on films) and be hilarious, but the boy Ethan with his all-knowing eyebrow hardly raises to aesthetic standards of Jewish comedy. He doesn’t wear his pj’s to let the audience laugh at him, he wears them because it’s like irony dude: you think he’s a dork, but he’s actually brilliant, and to make sure we all get that he’s brilliant he makes a haughty face. He’s not funny, he’s irritating, and his “comedy” is designed to defend existing power structures.
One problem with American secular Jews is that they don’t know how to be secular Jews. Russian Jews are for the most part non-believers, but would a Russian Jew ever brag, like The Forward-defended twenty-something, “We have no morals”? No, that’s wholly idiotic, because, as Jews, we have to understand that our greatest contribution to civilization was the introduction of monotheism. Only Jews totally oblivious to their heritage can run around yapping about “no morals”.
Equally antithetic to anything Jewish is boy Ethan’s one venture into the abortion debate, which he admits he lost, but:
To this day, I haven’t fact checked Chip’s scientific report. Beyond the women’s rights implications, I’m afraid it would be the ultimate surrender if I knew the truth.