sitting on the edge of the sandbox, biting my tongue

August 16, 2011

Russia in Afghanistan

Filed under: politics, Russia — Tags: , , — edge of the sandbox @ 11:02 am

That Afghanistan is a grave of empires is one of those endlessly recycled cliches with Russian experience sited as an example.

Soviet involvement in Afghanistan lasted from 1979 to 1988; during this period 14,453 Soviet troops were killed, or about 1,500 a year.  What’s 15,000 men for a country like Russia?  For comparison, the Soviet Union lost almost 27,000,000 soldiers and civilians in four years of the Russian involvement in World War II, with 80,000 dead in the final battle of the war alone.  Of course, that was under very different circumstances, the country was attacked, and the German onslaught stopped only on the outskirts of Moscow.  That’s true.  But imagine the mentality of people weaned on stories of the Great Patriotic war and the many millions lost.  While the Afghan war was unpopular, the 15,000 figure did not weigh too heavily on the Russian psyche, and in any event, even during Perestroika,  the Soviet Union was not a Western-style democracy, we didn’t have a large-scale anti-war movement, and there was a draft.  If the Politburo wanted to stay in Afghanistan, they would.

In any event, the Soviet empire fell apart a few years after the withdrawal from Afghanistan for domestic political and economic reasons.  Russia lost such prized possessions as Czechoslovakia, the Soviet Socialist Republic of Estonia and the Early Medieval Russian capital of Kiev.  Because of alcoholism, 25% of Russian men today are expected to die before age 55.  So, again, what’s 1,500 war dead a year?  I’m not even mentioning the Chechen wars.  OK, I just mentioned them.

One among many Russian Afghan War memorials, this one in Yekaterinburg.

Certainly, the war wasn’t free, but the cost of the Afghan war should be looked at in the context of the stagnant economy.  To make things worse, in the second half of the 1980s revenue fell as Gorbachev launched his anti-alcoholism campaign, significantly reducing the monies collected from vodka taxes.  Incredibly, vodka taxes constituted a quarter of Soviet budget.  All that as the Soviet Union was also trying to keep up with the arms race.  Withdrawal from Afghanistan didn’t save the Soviet economy.

Not to say that the Soviet Union wasn’t overstretched.  Afghanistan is a land-locked country, and by the time you get there you know you are overstretched.  One of the reasons Afghanistan is not much of a nation today is because no foreign power really bothered to do much nation-building there.

Today, American war dead are a different story.  We mourn each and every hero, like the 31 killed in the recent helicopter crash.  But if we don’t fight wars for treasure, what exactly is our end game in that land-locked country, and how are we going to achieve it?  Certainly the US is not obligated to do any nation building there just because we helped the Afghans to kick out the Soviets.  Can we trust the current occupant of the White House to achieve anything at all in Central Asia?

Advertisements

4 Comments »

  1. We are kidding ourselves if we think we are going to change the Afghans.

    BTW, I spent three not so pleasant weeks in Yekaterinburg in November of 1992. The food was barely edible.

    Comment by Conservatives on Fire — August 16, 2011 @ 5:39 pm

  2. Just keeping the Taliban busy so they can’t allow a group like al Qaeda to reform and launch attacks on us. Afghanistan is hopeless. It is a failed state and has never been a real country just a highway on the road to someplace else.

    At least we’re not planing bombs in stuffed animals the way the Ruskies did. Speaking of which I knew a guy from Moscow who stabbed a guy in the stomach for sleeping with his ex-girlfriend. The Soviets said go to jail or Afghanistan. He became a sniper and shot many Afghans there. After doing that for a few years he left for the US. He told me it screwed him up so much he’d wished he would have chosen jail instead.

    The last guy he killed, he told me, was smoking a cigarette. Alex said he thought he should let the guy enjoy his smoke before putting a bullet in his brain. He was generous like that.

    Comment by h — August 16, 2011 @ 11:47 pm

  3. We are not winning hearts and minds in Afghanistan. We’ve been there 10 long years now!

    Ever read James A. Michener’s book Caravans? It does emphasize some important aspect about Afghanistan and how intractable the people can be.

    Every day, I hope to God that my USMC cousin who is serving in Afghanistan isn’t killed or wounded. He is only 21 years old.

    Comment by Always On Watch — August 17, 2011 @ 4:08 am

    • Conservatives on Fire,
      Oh, I don’t know, if we have 300 years and don’t mind wasting the lives of 1500 men a year, we might get somewhere. But what’s in it for us?
      I’m sure the food was horrible, unless you knew people who invited you to their kitchen. My mom was born in Ural Mountains (Chelyabinsk) in World War II.

      Harrison,
      I think our initial response in Afghanistan was about right. If AQ becomes a problem again, we can repeat that operation. Also, we shouldn’t be to generous with our money; it will be stolen.
      I doubt that guy will be any better in Russian prison. I wonder how he made it here with criminal record like his, unless there was no paper record. Technically, it’s not allowed, but since DHS decided immigration petitions on a case by vase basis, anything is possible.
      BTW my cousin married an Afghan war vet. He drove a truck there, a really nice man.

      Always On Watch,
      My thoughts go out to your cousin. I hope he’s safe and well.
      Thank you for the book recommendation. I added it to my amazon list.

      Comment by edge of the sandbox — August 17, 2011 @ 8:57 am


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: